Strengths and Weaknesses of Non-chemical Weed Management Strategies in Small-scale Vegetable Production

Mahbuba Ferdous *

Department of Agricultural Extension, Ministry of Agriculture, Bangladesh and University of New England, Australia.

*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.


Weeds are continuing to create problems for vegetable growers more than ever before due to climate change, frequent cultivation, and the evolution of herbicide resistance. Weeds not only decrease vegetable yields but also reduce their quality. This case study aims to investigate weed management strategies, their strengths and weaknesses, and, the scope for improvements in a small-scale vegetable garden in Australia. The Armidale community garden in the New England region was selected for this study because of its wider types of vegetable production. The data was collected by observing and, taking an in-depth and unstructured interview of the convener of the garden. The study showed that the growers only use non-chemical weed management strategies to tackle the predicament. Mechanical and cultural methods including mulching, hand weeding, tillage, and grazing are mainly used to manage the weed infestation in the vegetable garden. Among them mulching with wood chips and hand weeding were considered more effective in minimizing the weed competition during the critical periods of crop development but they could not reach a satisfactory level. Thus, further improvements by integrating several approaches simultaneously are needed to control weeds more effectively and economically. The outcomes of the study will benefit both conventional and organic vegetable producers as well as researchers to keep weed populations at a manageable level.

Keywords: Weed management, community garden, integrated methods, mulching, hand weeding, tillage, crop rotation

How to Cite

Ferdous , Mahbuba. 2023. “Strengths and Weaknesses of Non-Chemical Weed Management Strategies in Small-Scale Vegetable Production”. Asian Journal of Advances in Agricultural Research 23 (2):1-10.


Download data is not yet available.


Coleman MJ, Sindel BM, van der Meulen AW, Reeve IJ. The risks associated with weed spread in Australia and implications for natural areas. Natural Areas Journal 2011;31:368-376.

Sindel BM. Weeds and their impact. In: Sindel BM, editor. Australian weed management systems, Melbourne: R.G. & F.J. Richardson. 2000;3-16.

Robert ELN. Weed management handbook. 9th ed. British Crop Protection Council, Uk: Blackwell Science; 2002.


Ansong M, Pickering C. What's a Weed? Knowledge, attitude and behaviour of park visitors about weeds. PLoS ONE. 2015;10:1-14.

Berenger M. Australia's new approach to tackling our billion-dollar pest animal and weed problem. Australian Veterinary Journal. 2017;95:8-9.

Willmott J. Making the move from traditional to contemporary weed management. Plant Protection Quarterly. 2013;28:73-74.

Sinden J, Jones R, Hester S, Odom D, Kalisch C, James R, Cacho O. The economic impact of weeds in Australia. Technical Series 8, CRC for Australian Weed Management; 2004.


McLeod R. Annual costs of weeds in Australia. Centre for Invasive Species Solutions, Canberra; 2018.


Islam F, Wang J, Farooq MA, Khan MSS, Xu L, Zhu J, Zhao M, Muños S, Li QX, Zhou W. Potential impact of the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid on human and ecosystems. Environment International. 2018;111:332–351.

Available: envint.2017.10.020

Kristiansen P, Coleman M, Fyfe C, Sindel BM. Weed management for the Australian vegetable industry: Final report. Horticulture Australia limited. University of New England; 2014.


Kristiansen P, Coleman M, Fyfe C, Sindel BM. Weed management for the vegetable industry-Scoping study. Horticulture Innovation Australia, Sydney; 2015.

Kristiansen PE. Sustainable weed management in organic herb and vegetable production. PhD dissertation. University of New England; 2003.

Parry S, Shrestha A. Effects of weed-free periods on organic romaine lettuce production. Journal of Crop Improvement. 2018;32(1):124-139. Available:

Sindel BM, Coleman M, Kristiansen P, Reeve I. Sustainable broadleaf weed control in cucurbit crops. Final Report. VG10048. Horticulture Australia. 2011;3-29. Available: scoping-study-for-sustainable-broadleaf-weed-control-in-cucurbit-crops-vg10048.pdf

Ruttledge A, Whalley RDB, Reeve I, Backhouse DA, Sindel BM. Preventing weed spread: A survey of lifestyle and commercial landholders about in the Northern Tablelands of New South Wales, Australia. The Rangeland Journal. 2015; 37:409-423.

DOI: 10.1071/RJ15010

Preston C. Herbicide mode of action and herbicide resistance. In: Sindel BM, editor. Australian weed management systems, Melbourne: R.G. & F.J. Richardson. 2000;209-226.

Wikipedia; 2017. Available:,_New_South_Wales

Anonymous. The Armidale Community Garden; 2015.

Accessed 17 June 2018.

Emma D. Community Gardens Australia; 2022.

Accessed 15 April 2023 Available:

ABN.765 052 285 56.

Anonymous. Sustainable Living Armidale; 2023.

Accesses 15 April 2023. Available:

Kristiansen P, Sindel BM, Jessop R. Agronomic and economic evaluation of weed management methods in organic herb and vegetable production systems. Proceedings of the 11th Australian Agronomy Conference. 2003;4-1.

Khan BA. Implications of mulching on weed management in crops and vegetable. In: Akhtar K, Arif M, Riaz M, Wang H, editors. Mulching in Agroecosystems, Singapore: Springer; 2022.


Billeaud LA, Zajicek JM. Influence of mulches on weed control, soil pH, soil nitrogen content, and growth of Ligustrum japonicum. Journal of Environmental Horticulture.1989;7:155-157.

Arentoft B, Ali A, Streibig J, Andreasen C. A new method to evaluate the weed-suppressing effect of mulches: a comparison between spruce bark and cocoa husk mulches. Weed Research 2013;53:169-175.

DOI: 10.1111/wre.12011

Pannacci E, Lattanzi B, Tei F. Non-chemical weed management strategies in minor crops: A review. Crop Protection. 2017;96:44-58.

Pratley JE. Tillage and other physical management methods. In: Sindel BM, editor. Australian weed management systems, Melbourne: R.G. & F.J. Richardson. 2000:105-122.

Sita T, Sindel BM, Smart N, Coleman MJ, Fyfe C, Lawlor C,Vo B, Kristiansen P. Hand weeding tools in vegetable production systems: an agronomic, ergonomic and economic evaluation. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability. 2022;20(4):659-674. DOI: 10.1080/14735903.2021.1964789

Asgarpoor R, Ghorbani R, Koocheki A, Mohammad-Abadi A. Effects of integrated weed management using solarization, straw mulch and hand-weeding on weed seed-bank. Pizhūhishhā-yi zirā̒ī-i Īrān. 2011;8:424-430.

Kemp DR, Friend DA. Grazing management methods. In: Sindel BM, editor. Australian weed management systems, Melbourne: R.G. & F.J. Richardson. 2000;139-160.

Bajwa AA, Walsh M, Chauhan BS. Weed management using crop competition in Australia. Crop Protection. 2017;95:8. DOI: 10.1016/j.cropro.2016.08.021